null
Agar vs. Gellan Gum: Which to Choose?

Agar vs. Gellan Gum: Which to Choose?

Agar vs. Gellan Gum: Which to Choose?

Agar vs. Gellan Gum: Which to Choose?

Anjali Singh

Nov 05, 2020

Share this article:

Plants, like all other living organisms on earth, require minerals and nutrients for their growth and development. In nature, soil acts as a nutrient reservoir and the support system for their establishment at a place. However, what happens when they are brought to labs?

Growing plants in a lab environment is a tough job, as specific nutrient requirements of the plant need must be fulfilled for its survival. And that’s not it! They also require a particular environment, with specific temperatures and humidity at different growing stages. However, the solution to all these problems is available today.

Specific machines have been developed to set the temperature and humidity of the room in which plants are grown. For nutrient supply, different types of media are available that fulfill the nutrient requirement of the plants. But, what provides the stability in the media? What holds it firmly for its establishment in the media? The answer to these questions is "solidifying agents".

Solidifying agents are added to the media to create a semi-solid/solid surface for the explants cultured in the media. The agents help the explants to establish themselves and grow. Different solidifying agents are present to date such as agar, alginate, phytagel, and transfer gel. Each of this is slightly different in characteristics (solidifying temperature, pH) and serve different purposes. These gelling agents have a strong influence on the growth and development of various explants.

In this article, we'll discuss the properties and applications of agar and gellan gum.

Preference Center

Agar

Agar is a mixture of agarose (a linear polysaccharide) and agaropectin (a heterogeneous mixture of smaller molecules). It is obtained from the cell walls of a species of red algae, Gelidium corneum and tengusa, and Gracilaria ogonori (division Rhodophyta), as an amorphous and translucent product. It is commercially available in the form of powder and mixed with media and water for the growth of microorganisms, plant cells, or tissues.

It is the most common gelling agent used in plant tissue culture. The solidification of the agar is pH-dependent and the optimal pH range occurs between 5.2 and 5.6. The pH of the media should be adjusted after adding agar. It dissolves readily in boiling water and solidifies at 37℃ into a firm gel. The normal concentration range of agar added in the media is 6-8 g/L (0.5%-10%). Agar is stable for a prolonged period and does not bind excessively with media components.

Gellan Gum

Gellan gum was isolated and discovered in 1978 from a bacteria Sphingomonas elodea. It is a water-soluble anionic polysaccharide, initially used as a substitute for agar in various clinical bacteriological media. Structurally, it is composed of a repeating unit of tetrasaccharide, which consists of two residues of D-glucose, one residue of L-rhamnose, and one residue of D-glucuronic acid.

Gellan gum products fall into two categories, depending on the number of acetate groups attached to the polymer. The products containing fewer acetate groups form firm, non-elastic, brittle gels, whereas the products containing a large number of acetate groups form soft and elastic gels.

Gellan gum products, when added to the media, produce a more transparent gel, which allows for better observation of root growth, identification of contamination at an early stage, and facilitates light for microscopic analysis of tissue or cells, which is difficult to achieve with agar. They are also very useful in culturing thermophilic microorganisms.

Gellan gums can withstand temperatures up to 120 ℃ and only half its strength is required to reach an equivalent gel strength as agar. In long-term cultures, gellan gums tend to liquefy because of disturbance in structural crosslinking on pH change and depletion of salts. It is added to the media in a concentration range of 2-4 g/L. When adding gellan gums to media, rapidly stir your mixture at room temperature to avoid clumping.

The 0.2% of gellan gum added to the media can substantially modify the MS medium concerning elements like Na (sodium), Al (aluminum), Sr (strontium), Ti (titanium), Cu (copper), and V (vanadium). Whereas agar only disturbs a bit of the sulfur and silica composition in the media. Further, agar has phenolic impurities, where no such impurity is present in gellan gum.

A chart showing differences in Agar and Gellan gum.

PropertiesAgarGellan Gum
Melting temperature85℃110℃
Gelling temperature37℃Low acyl gellan gum products: 25 ℃

High acyl gellan gum products: 65 ℃

Concentration6-8 g/L (0.5%-10%)2-4 g/L (0.2-0.4%)
TransparencyLow (cloudy)Very high
Modification of MS mediaModify by altering sulfur, calcium, and silicon in the mediaModify by altering Na, Al, Sr, Ti, Cu, and V in the media.
Phenolic impurityPresentAbsent
PriceCheaper than gellan gumCostlier than agar
Application
  • Can be used to grow bacteria growing at moderate temperature
  • Can be used for plant tissue culture application like somatic embryogenesis etc.
  • Can be used to grow bacteria growing at extremely high temperature
  • To observe root growth
  • To analyze tissue or cells
  • In plant tissue culture

The choice of gelling agent also depends on your experiments, so other than the concentration, price, and transparency of gel, some other factors need to be determined. For example, some studies have shown that seeds of rice, when grown on agar and gellan gum, showed the same growth rate. So, consider all properties and your requirements before you choose any solidifying agents for your cultures!

References

  1. Scherer, P. A., Müller, E., Lippert, H., & Wolff, G. (1988). MULTIELEMENT ANALYSIS OF AGAR AND GELRITE IMPURITIES INVESTIGATED BY INDUCTIVELY COUPLED PLASMA EMISSION SPECTROMETRY AS WELL AS PHYSICAL PROPERTIES OF TISSUE CULTURE MEDIA PREPARED WITH AGAR OR THE GELLAN GUM GELRITE. Acta Horticulturae, (226), 655–658. DOI:10.17660/actahortic.1988.226.9
  2. https://phytotechlab.com/media/documents/ProductLi...
  3. https://www.britannica.com/topic/agar-seaweed-prod...
  4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agar
  5. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gellan_gum.

Got a Plant Tissue Culture or Plant Cell Technology story to share?

Anjali
Anjali Singh, MS

We'd love to hear from you! Send your suggestions and story to Anjali Singh at anjali@plantcelltechnology.com.

Anjali is our Scientific Content Creator and Community Manager, bringing her expertise in tissue culture, an MS in Plant Biotechnology, and research skills. She writes articles about tissue culture, answers questions, and addresses concerns about our products.

Anjali has also ghostwritten engaging articles for Biotech and Life Science companies and runs her own page, "scienceshuttle," making science accessible and fun. When she's not immersed in scientific writing, Anjali indulges in her passions for gardening, drawing, and reading books. Connect with Anjali on Linkedin and Twitter to stay updated on her latest endeavors.